"This is going to sound arrogant, but my presence is charity. Just who I am." - JAY Z
Recently in an
interview with Rap Radar, Jay Z offered that his simple presence on the planet Earth alone, as an incredibly successful black man, a mogul, was charity alone. He likened himself to President Obama, Shakespeare, and Jean-Michel Basquiat and dismissed assertions that he was not living up to a larger social responsibility. This was mostly in response to basic criticism he received from legendary activist, actor, musician, Harry Belafonte, in which Belafonte implied Jay Z could do a lot more with his star power.
So, does Jay Z have a valid point, or is he another out of touch super-star with a God complex?
Personally, my presence is also charity, that is, if I am volunteering, or raising some money for a great cause (like
Mural Music & Arts Project). Otherwise my presence is just a voice on the net (or on a rap beat). But, that's not charity. That's just speaking your conscience. Unfortunately, you can't write that off. However, I am no Jay Z. My presence alone doesn't influence millions of people. That being said, what kind of influence is Jigga emitting with his mere presence? And is "charity" alone enough when it comes to larger social responsibility?
Lots of people participate in acts of charity but a lot less engage in social movements for change. It is very popular to send money to Africa but at the same time many people don't wanna think about helping their neighbors down the street, or across the tracks, or the bridge. Folks will gladly give to cancer research but a homeless person with mental illness and drug addiction, "get them bums outta my city! No, you can't have any quarters."
Not that honest charity isn't a great thing, it's awesome. Especially when regular folks give money, or time, or items, even when they themselves don't have much. Even if its just a few bucks here and there, that's a great practice. But charity from a hundred millionaire or billionaire, that writes it off, and makes themselves feel grandiose in gesture, but remains disconnected from the people... to quote Shania Twain, "that don't impress me much."
So, when one of these elite of the elite, says their mere presence alone is charity, well, just comes off as pathetically pompous. But, when that same "charitable" person happens to be the one and only JAY-Z, a black man in America that was once a crack dealer in the Marcy projects, and is now one of the most influential, most famous human beings on the planet, its more than pompous, its sad and to some it is infuriating and disrespectful. If Jay, took some time to reflect on those that came before him, who gave so much more than charity, he'd be better served personally but so would our poor communities of color, and the greater American conversation in general.

Imagine Muhammad Ali, in 1966 standing up and saying, "my presence is charity" in a serious sense… right before he took no position on the Vietnam war. It may not seem like a big deal (that he did quite the opposite), as Ali's legend is now romanticized but back then it was a heroically bold and risky move, not just in solidarity with the peace movement, but more so with the plight of black America in the 1960's. The champ was subsequently labeled a fool, arrogant, treasonous, traitor, and as a famous sportswriter said, "he became a nigger again." He never ended up doing jail time, but he was sentenced to 5 years (which he appealed repeatedly and was ultimately overturned by the Supreme Court), and he was then stripped of his heavyweight title in his prime, lost big sponsor dollars, and couldn't find work. He was the greatest boxer alive (arguably of all-time) and he wasn't allowed to fight because he opted to fight for a bigger cause. He was broke, written off by much of America, and essentially left for dead. He would ultimately overcome all of the hatred and opposition and return to greatness, knocking out the unmovable young George Foreman in Kinshasa, Zaire in the "
Rumble of the Jungle" in 1974. Today, in a much different America he is considered one of the greatest Americans to ever live, and was honored as such in 1996 (only 30 years later) when he lit the Olympic flame in Atlanta.

As Ali once said though, he was only accepted with open arms at a distance by white America as long as he was declaring to be "the greatest alive" and knocking people out inside the ring. As soon as he became Muslim, and voiced opposition to going to Vietnam because "no Vietcong ever called me nigger," he was suddenly demonized and hated. But that was the 1960's, and Ali didn't have hundreds of millions of dollars and a seat next to the President. He had so much more to risk than Sean Carter (Jay Z), yet Carter seems to feel no need to step out of bounds these days. He's quite comfortable representing "
Tom Ford" and staying in his lane. To me, he is the exact opposite of the great Ali. He hoots and hollers that he's the greatest of all-time like Ali but he doesn't stand for much more than that bombastic bravado. He may indeed feel good about himself because he "drops a jewel" here and there and gives anonymously large sums of money but I think there's a larger responsibility. He's sort of the Malcolm X of our modern times. Except in 2013, Detroit Red rises to fame for his quick wit and sharp tongue and ultimately opts to hang with the elite bourgeoisie instead of calling out the injustices of the status quo and demanding more from everyone across the board. Indeed the man has a 5 Million dollar watch (his wife gave him), but doesn't seem to know the time.
Just recently, in an
interview with MSNBC's Chris Hayes, Belafonte moved to quash all the rhetoric between himself and Jay Z, and called upon Jay and his wife to a sit-down to clear the air and attempt to come together to use their collective star power for the greater good of Black America. Belafonte has also recently added his presence to the "Dream Defenders", a group of young people seeking social justice in Florida whom are currently occupying the state Capitol building, demanding that they will not leave until the state rethinks its "Stand Your Ground" laws. Since the George Zimmerman trial, these laws have been exposed as biased in favor of whites and to the violent detriment of blacks. In the interview, Belafonte stated that he was lending his voice, wisdom, and star power to the "Dream Defenders" cause and made light of the massive star power that black America currently holds but does not fully utilize. He referenced the difference between this usage of star power today and decades prior when there was a larger sense of social responsibility and unity within the black community. In regard to Jay Z, he swiftly stated that he wasn't going to comment on what Jay Z should do (in response to calls for him to boycott concerts in the state of Florida) but that he could only comment on things Jay Z is NOT doing.
Ironically, in the very same Rap Radar interview in which Jay exclaimed his presence is charity, he also oddly commented on the verdict of the Zimmerman trial. He appeared to be very surprised by the ruling and strangely remarked that he knew there was still "a bit of racism" in America but was shocked by the outcome. It is very telling that a man who once sold crack cocaine in the Marcy projects because he saw no other way out, and would later rap about being racially profiled by police in "99 Problems" would somehow in 2013 be suddenly surprised by the Zimmerman verdict. Not to mention the fact that he actually used the language that America still has "a bit of racism." This disconnect with his own past, let alone his neglect and disrespect of the greats who came before him truly exposes Jay Z as an out of touch super-star with a very shallow vision, emptied it seems by the pitfalls of success and his love affair with capitalism. How else do you explain such naivete? Because one would think that a man as street smart, business savvy, and lyrically adroit as Jay Z could be enlightened enough to connect the dots between the profiling and murder of Trayvon Martin, the systems bias treatment of the case, the subsequent not guilty verdict, and the necessity for someone as influential as himself to give a little more than merely his grand presence.
#MyPresenceIsCharity